So, this novel has five parts over the course of its 440-ish pages, and two of those parts aren't really necessary--or even meaningful--to what passes for the story in it, unless Ms. Allan was trying to play Man in the High Castle games, which ... sure, I guess; in some ways it's a treat to read someone do that who (to all appearances) is not doing methamphetamines and/or hallucinogens while suffering from delusional mental illness--I mean, this novel is coherent, man--but there's really no sense of the characters in the SF portions breaking through their reality to understand what's outside it. It seems pretty clear to me that the messages those characters are understanding to be "alien" are in fact bits of the author bleeding into the fiction she's writing. The sort of matryoshka doll narrative the author is doing almost always, in my experience, founders on the shoals of the novel itself being a layer between the reader and the characters; it does the opposite of engaging and/or enabling willing suspension of disbelief. The prose here is pretty decent, and some of the characters seem plausible; the real-world in England seems lived-in, the SF world seems ... thin, I think: It doesn't seem all that well thought out, though that might be intentional-ish (which is a choice, if a dubious one). The SF story here never really goes anywhere, possibly because the matryoshka dolls fit too well, or maybe not well enough; the real-world story seems more interesting, but it's really fragmentary. Clearly the idea is the author in the real-world sections is writing the SF stuff to try to make sense of things in her life, which makes me think this isn't really an SF story; but that could just be me. Not super-great, but at least not unreadable on a moment-to-moment basis.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The Race by Nina Allan
So, this novel has five parts over the course of its 440-ish pages, and two of those parts aren't really necessary--or even meaningful...
-
So, this was a book that I almost stopped reading a couple-three times. It's not *bad*, exactly, but it's a weird dissonant tonal ...
-
This is an intricate novel, probably overcomplicated for the story it tells, with antecedents ranging from Barker to Borges to folklore fr...
-
So after reading one of Kreuger's novels, I've grabbed another one. They stand alone just fine, but there's some pleasure in s...
No comments:
Post a Comment