So, this novel has five parts over the course of its 440-ish pages, and two of those parts aren't really necessary--or even meaningful--to what passes for the story in it, unless Ms. Allan was trying to play Man in the High Castle games, which ... sure, I guess; in some ways it's a treat to read someone do that who (to all appearances) is not doing methamphetamines and/or hallucinogens while suffering from delusional mental illness--I mean, this novel is coherent, man--but there's really no sense of the characters in the SF portions breaking through their reality to understand what's outside it. It seems pretty clear to me that the messages those characters are understanding to be "alien" are in fact bits of the author bleeding into the fiction she's writing. The sort of matryoshka doll narrative the author is doing almost always, in my experience, founders on the shoals of the novel itself being a layer between the reader and the characters; it does the opposite of engaging and/or enabling willing suspension of disbelief. The prose here is pretty decent, and some of the characters seem plausible; the real-world in England seems lived-in, the SF world seems ... thin, I think: It doesn't seem all that well thought out, though that might be intentional-ish (which is a choice, if a dubious one). The SF story here never really goes anywhere, possibly because the matryoshka dolls fit too well, or maybe not well enough; the real-world story seems more interesting, but it's really fragmentary. Clearly the idea is the author in the real-world sections is writing the SF stuff to try to make sense of things in her life, which makes me think this isn't really an SF story; but that could just be me. Not super-great, but at least not unreadable on a moment-to-moment basis.
Shallow Book Thoughts
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Thursday, November 19, 2026
The Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck
Unexpected two-day Reading Project--it's a chonkier book than I thought, and dense (though the prose is often surprisingly beautiful). It's a grim book, occasionally bordering on relentless--though that is sort of a realistic relentlessness, or perhaps a relentless realism--though it's always a human one, the bad things that happen are mostly human bad things, and the good things that happen are mostly human good things. The drought and dust storms at the start are natural, and the deluge at the end is natural, but they're unsupportable, or even unsurvivable, because of human actions, societal things and business and what we'd probably call jokingly "late capitalism" but the novel's almost a hundred years old and maybe we haven't learned all that much but we've been lucky for a while; and maybe our luck's about to run out. The book's politics are occasionally kinda incoherent--there arguably aren't a lot of practical solutions offered, especially when it's the rich folks as has the guns and the sheriff and his deputies in their warm and moneyed hands--but they're not like particularly hard to decipher, and they're mostly at least not wrong. The characters in it feel like real people, and their pains are almost immiserating; their fleeting joys are like a sparkle in the air. The story doesn't really resolve in any conventional sense, but things do reach something of a clear stopping point, partly about a new year coming in and partly about the people in the novel maybe coming to a point of something like collective action. And I don't know where any novelist could have gone after the last scene in the novel. Amazing and brutal and human stuff.
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
May We Feed the King by Rebecca Perry
Um. Pretty much the opposite of last night's book, to the extent that I feel almost as though I have whiplash. The prose is luminous, but the story ... the story really doesn't do much. It places bets it never really acknowledges, let alone pays off. It staggers and maunders through something in the present day, then wanders around in the past for a while, then snaps back to the present day. There's some incident, but it appears kinda secondary to atmosphere, mostly a sense that we're supposed to pity (or something on those lines, anyway) the characters: the specialist in museum displays, who seems to be suffering from grief or trauma or something; the king in the past, who's maybe bipolar or maybe just flat uninterested in being king or doing the things his council of advisors expect him to. My takeaways are that the display artist needs to get some serious psychiatric help, possibly get on some really good meds to get her neurochemistry back to something workable; and that the king who did nothing was probably the best possible king. Somehow I do not believe those are the intended takeaways. No joy in Mudville.
Monday, November 16, 2026
The Hook by Donald E. Westlake
Westlake at peak form was really, really good, and this seems to have been Westlake at peak form, or so close as to make no odds. The wit is there, the prose dances and sparkles, there were moments that had me chuckling or even laughing; but the story starts with some people making some dark and arguably desperate choices and just unravels from there. It's not a mystery of any kind, it's not even pretending to abide by any "Fair Play" rules, but every time things ratchet, every time the tension clicks and clanks up, every bad thing that gets worse is rooted in and built on something that has happened, everything in the novel feels like a natural result. There's some vaguely meta inside-baseball stuff, since the story is closely tied to publishing (far as I know all the names are made-up, but the business seems plausible). There's commentary on publishing, here, but also stuff about professional and personal envy, and about what people will do to attain or sustain success, and for a novel in which even the "good people" are at least in on a murder, it takes a pretty firm moral stance by the end--and the ending is kinda like getting shivved in the ribs. Very much like licking an electric light socket, in all the good ways.
Thursday, November 12, 2026
All the Dark Places by Terry Parlato
Another day, another mediocre novel. Cluttered story, stolid prose. For a novel arguably about a serial killer it didn't really seem to have much in the way of stakes: Other than the murder that was the instigating event, there was some not super-competent violence, but no one actually died; and the people who got hurt seemed to recover on all levels really rapidly. There's the "first person narrator who's not telling you something" thing going on for a long time, which doesn't make me like the book. Some of the characters almost threatened to be interesting, but they were hammered down and muffled. At least it wasn't repeated pointless twists.
Wednesday, November 11, 2026
Tinfoil Butterfly by Rachel Eve Moulton
This is not a very good novel. It seems to have emerged from something like writing exercises while the author was in college or maybe grad school, and while clearly some part of it stuck in her head and she kept working on it, she really probably should have left it as the exercise. The first-person POV is something of a knot of pain, self-loathing, and addiction--and also self-harm; she's not a pleasant character to share one's head with. The other characters are I guess supposed to be grimy-gritty sorts you might find on the road in the middle of nowhere (whether the Black Hills counts as the middle of nowhere is probably a matter of opinion) except I guess for the pre-pubescent trans boy. There's a lot of not-real-competent violence in the novel, people seem unable to actually kill each other, though they do from time to time hurt each other good. The novel's biggest problem, though, is that it seems unable to make up its mind about some things in the novel that arguably seem supernatural, but the POV is just too screwed up in multiple ways to just accept their narration in point. "Unreliable narrator of possibly supernatural story" is basically the Henry James approach to horror, and it's not a great approach. The novel is probably trying to say things about women on present-day American society, and I'd probably agree with those things, but the novel doesn't work on the level of story, let alone on the level of subtext.
Monday, November 9, 2026
Frankenstein by Mary Shelley
It turns out this was published less than a hundred years after what (best I can tell) are considered to be the earliest English-language novels, and the fact that "novel" wasn't entirely an established form, yet (outside of length) shows. What kept kicking me out, though wasn't the two-hundred-year-old novel-quirks; it was the two-hundred-year-old science. Shelley at least has the ... presence of mind, I guess, to keep the actual mechanics of Victor's work obscured--and his determination that his secrets should die with him is a reasonable enough plot point. The structure, with at least three layers of nested narrative, is one that occasionally surfaces today, in novels as different from each other as *Cloud Atlas* and *The Buffalo Hunter Hunter*, though Shelley doesn't seem to even try (or feel expected to) muster the shifts in narrative register Stephen Graham Jones handles so gracefully in the latter. Some of the ... contrivances in the story are wacky and almost laughable; there's often not a lot of difference in prosody between narration and dialogue, let alone difference in character voice; the epistolary nature kinda clunks along, as it tends to, managing little more than to frame the first-person narratives. It still has some kick, though, and the thematics of it pack some punch; it's clear why it lingers in the cultural subconscious (though most of that's probably due at least as much to James Whale and Boris Karloff as it is to Mary Shelley).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
The Race by Nina Allan
So, this novel has five parts over the course of its 440-ish pages, and two of those parts aren't really necessary--or even meaningful...
-
So, this was a book that I almost stopped reading a couple-three times. It's not *bad*, exactly, but it's a weird dissonant tonal ...
-
This is an intricate novel, probably overcomplicated for the story it tells, with antecedents ranging from Barker to Borges to folklore fr...
-
So after reading one of Kreuger's novels, I've grabbed another one. They stand alone just fine, but there's some pleasure in s...





